Wednesday, September 23, 2015

O R O P : VETERANS DON'T NEED ************** INDIA'S FIFTH COLUMN






                          VETERANS DON'T NEED

                           INDIA'S  FIFTH  COLUMN



                





Dear Fellow Veterans, 

Press release as pasted below has been sent to the media.
Let’s see how many publish it. 

It has also been sent to some MPs whose
mail IDs are with me , with a false hope that some of those worthies
might take note of it. 

Regards,

                                          Harwant 






********************************************************************************************************

                        PRESS RELEASE 



                 EX-SERVICEMEN REJECT 

                            ‘DILUTED’ 

                                 AND 

                          ‘TRUNCATED’

                ONE RANK ONE PENSION 




1. In a layman’s language, One Rank One Pension 
(OROP). means that no
senior (with more length of 
service) military person would get
less pension than his 
junior (less length of service) of the same
rank. The 
Parliamentary(Koshiyari) Committee defined it, that the, 
“OROP implies that uniform pension be paid to Armed 
Forces personnel
retiring in the same rank with the same 
length of service,
irrespective of their date of retirement, 
and any future enhancement
in the rates of This implies  
bridging the gap between the rate of pensions
of the 
current pensioners and the past pensioners and also 
future
enhancements in the rate of pension to be 
automatically passed on to
the past pensioners.” 



2. The Govt’s acceptance of the OROP on 05 September 
was due to
Ex-Servicemen’s ongoing four decades long 
agitation and under the RSS
pressure, as also to enhance 
its chances of winning the forthcoming
Bihar assembly 
election. The Raksha Mantri stated on implementation
of 
the OROP, that the pension would be equalized after 
every five
years, instead of it being done annually, and 
that the figures would
be ‘mean’ of the maximum and 
minimum pensions of the same rank and
length of 
service. The United Front of Ex-Servicemen (UFESM) 
completely rejects this ‘Diluted’ and ‘Truncated’ OROP, 
as it has
destroyed the very definition, accepted in the 
Parliament , by both
the previous UPA and the present 
NDA Govts. Following issues are
highlighted:-


 (a) If implemented, it will be One Rank And Five Pensions , whereas, what had been assured and approved in the Parliament is “One
Rank One Pension”.



 (b) Diluted OROP will result in seniors drawing less pension than
the juniors, which is against the Hon'ble Supreme Court’s judgment
and hence not acceptable. 



(c) Mischievously , VRS was introduced in the note read out by
the Raksha Mantrti , whereas the Defence Services have no such ‘Golden
Handshake Scheme’. We have premature retirement for those who retire
after completing minimum pensionable service and for whom 
implementation of the OROP is mandatory . Any denial, 
besides being
illegal will be gravely unjust. 




(d) The Govt has claimed that calculating annual equalisation
would be a ‘mathematical nightmare’. Nothing can be farther from truth
as the software already exists for annual equalisation, as per the
approved definition by the Parliament, by the press of a button. 



(e) On 16 February’15 the Govt had stated in the Hon'ble
Supreme Court that it would implement OROP within three months. That
was NOT done. Again on 08 July the Govt stated in the Hon'ble Supreme
Court, that it would implement it within a week, only to go back on
its 
commitment. Is this ‘good governance’? Why this 
injustice to the
soldiers? 



(f) At Chandigarh, on 11 September ’15 , the Prime Minister
said that he had to deprive the poor to implement OROP. This is an extremely disrespectful and demeaning statement to the dignity of the
soldiers and has caused them extreme anguish . As almost all soldiers
come from poorest of the poor background, giving them some financial
justice must not be resented and spoken of in terms the Prime Minister
has done . 




(g) Why is the Govt not talking of expenditure incurred on
account of Non Functional Upgradation (NFU) awarded to 58 Group A
services - and, now even police and para military forces are including
in it, by the High Court? This is a whooping Rs 21000 crores per year
and will reach Rs 30,000 crores annually! In fact this is the
sacrifice of the poor man’s money which is paid for “Non- Functioning”
of the Babus and vast canteen subsidies of the MPs.




 (h) It is a clear failure of the society if the soldiers need to
descend to the streets to ask for their rights
3. To protest against the Govt’s anti Ex-Servicemen stance, a
huge Ekta Rally was held at the Jantar Mantar, New Delhi, on 12 September ‘15. About 200 buses going for the Rally were stopped on
the outskirts of Delhi and the media was gagged by the Govt .Now to
defame the Ex-Servicemen, some articles have suddenly been published
which appear to be at the behest of the Govt .






 4. In view of the foregoing, we strongly demand that the
above mentioned anomalies be rectified and the O.R.O.P. be implemented
as per its original definition, accepted by the Parliament and a
‘Notification’ to that effect be 
issued immediately. 




 {BRIG HARWANT SINGH (RETD)} , 

President
The All India Defence Brotherhood (Regd)


 (A constituent of the United Front of Ex-Servicemen) 


 54, Phase -7 , Mohali , (Pb) } .


 Phones :- 09814432554 and 

08054397206









































Tuesday, September 22, 2015

OROP : CHETAN BHAGAT A NEW ENTRY IN EXCLUSIVITY OF "PRESSITUTES "




                     CHETAN   BHAGAT  

             A NEW ENTRY IN EXCLUSIVITY 

                                                     OF 

                                         "PRESSITUTES "




"A Reply to Chetan Bhagat by King Fox-Wg Cdr Unni Kartha/Fox/37"
Refers Sunday Times Chetan Bhagat’s  ‘It’s time to analyse OROP with our head, not our heart’



Dear Chetan,

From your internet CV I gathered that your dad is (or was) an 
army officer (Lt Col) and your mom a NFU Govt employee in the 
agricultural ministry. I hope they are alive and well and 
pensionable ? If they are not, please accept my heartfelt 
sympathies. I too am an old, tired and retired soldier; perhaps a 
man like your dad. I can quite well imagine the trials and 
tribulations that you may have  faced in your youth, the trauma 
of a gypsy’s life, moving from one school to another, making a 
few cursory friend here or there, but growing up lonely and sad. 
Perhaps you never liked the disciplined life that your dad 
proscribed, did you dislike your dad or the army for it ? I noted 
from your CV that one or both your parents made great 
sacrifices, way beyond the call of duty, to put  you through IIT & 
IIM and spent money that they never had, to get you into a bank 
in Hong Kong, where despite 11 yrs of pampering at mind 
boggling salary, you were found a non-performer and cocked up 
the ‘khushi’ life facilitated by your doting parents. A loser. You 
then turned a writer and self-published banal, idiotic and highly 
unreadable trash. But I want you to  know that, because you are 
an army brat, I love you like a son. I am proud of your 
accomplishments, even if you sit on your brains, become a 
presstitute, turn Judas, and write articles like the one in ToI this 
morning with no clue about what you are writing – just like the 
trash I have written about you above.

‘Excuse Mois S’il Vous Plait’, the above was 
simply to prove a point to you, lacks veracity, 
conviction or evil intent – I am not a 
presstitute!!!



This style of insidious reportage, propaganda bending facts, ill-
conceived notions with a hidden agenda (like injecting a 
vaccine), paid reporting, or psy war, was invented by Dr 
Goebbels, the German propaganda minister during WW-II.


 Our  MoD now even has a Psy War Cell !!  Our venerable 
propaganda ministers (Jet Lee and Sharp Shooter R’Hore) are 
even more brilliant than Go or Mo Bhai,  and have encouraged 
elevation of insidious and obnoxious reportage to a fine art, 
with Pulitzer calibre presstitutes like Shekhar Gupta. Now you 
too. I congratulate you on your joining this exclusive band 
wagon, the intellectual whores. The media of every kind seems
 to be within the iron fist of the propaganda ministers, with the 
ability of blacking out even the internet (another report in ToI  
that Surat has been blacked out).  

The saddest part that I noticed this morning, at the end of your 
article, you have even solicited SMSs @ Rs 3 per sms. I presume 
that if 5 laks citizens and veterans send you hate sms, you would 
be richer by Rs 15 lks by this evening, that is besides what Lee & 
Hore Pvt Ltd, or ToI, must have paid you to write this deeply 
hurtful, but clever canard. You can now go laughing to  the bank 
when it opens tomorrow. I have also noted that within minutes 
your article has triggered an online battle between ill-informed 
supporters of BSF and the army.

  Well done ‘Beta’, that is 
exactly  what Lee & Hore Pvt Ltd wants. Screw the incredible 
Indian Army, Navy and AF, by bayonetting the hapless veterans.

Now  that you have set the cat amongst the aged veteran 
pigeons, I humbly request you to pay a visit to Jantar Mantar, 
talk to a few tired and retired soldiers like me on what is OROP 
all about ? Investigate the gross injustice perpetuated by 
successive Govts for 40 yrs. Read the Koshyari 
Committee Report, the SC judgement, and check out two all-
party parliamentary approvals, all about implementation of 
OROP which Lee, Chaddi & Hore Pvt Ltd doesn’t want to do 
using concocted and incredible arguments, God knows for what 
purpose or intent. I strongly recommend that you meet the 
functionaries of the OROP protest to hear what they have to say, 
ask Air Mshl Savoor Rtd about the actual financial implications. 
Find out the truth behind the evil machinations of Lee, Chaddi & 
Hore,  our GoI  Pvt Ltd.    

And after you do all these, fully educated yourself on the  subject
 of OROP, please sit and write another balanced analysis. I will 
then be even more proud of you, sing your praise all the way 
when I go to Valhalla. By the way the Lt Cols, Cols, Brigs and 
Generals (+ their equivalents), they are not fighting for  OROP, 
they are simply, peacefully, seeking justice; not for themselves, 
but for the men whom they commanded in peace or war, in the 
best traditions of the armed forces of India. So what if they are 
retired, it is a family like none other.

 Believe you me Chetan, if these old men start a 
fight, god bless you all.

Best regards
Jai Hind
Wg Cdr Unni Kartha (Rtd)

H No 90, Nakshatra Colony, Balapur,
Hyderabad, 500005
M[truncated by WhatsApp]



















OROP : OPS MAHASANGRAM The RHS entered its 100th day SEP22,2015


                         



OPS MAHASANGRAM  JANTAR MANTAR  The RHS entered its 100th day SEP22,2015

                     VETERANS DON'T NEED

            INDIA'S  FIFTH  COLUMN


               




The RHS entered its 100th day, with 17 individuals including a young lady army wife Ms Sudesh sitting it out today at JM.
 
Coinciding with the 100th day, was the felicitation ceremony by UFESM to those veterans who participated in the 1965 Indo-Pak war and having been invited by the Hon’ble Rashtrapati for high tea regretted their inability to attend due to the ongoing impasse over OROP for them. 
 
Over 25 gallantry award winners were felicitated by name while other participants were welcomed with bouquets and roses. The overall gathering was recorded as over 160 officers, JCO's, OR and families. The spirit of camaraderie and togetherness was infectious. Many a long lost colleague met and exchanged memories of those eventful days under fire. It was a sight to remember. The spirit of the solidarity was captured by the numerous cameras and reporters both from the electronic and print media who covered this glorious reunion.
 
In contrast we are informed that some seventy odd veterans did attend the reception at the Rashtrapati Bhawan but since the media except DD & ANI was not permitted an accurate assessment comment by us would not be apt.
 
The breakfast for RHS had been arranged by Brig Sudhir Kumar today. The lunch as usual was provided by the Gurudwara Bangla Sahib.
 
In a separate development certain e-mails and WA are being circulated by a motley group of ESM masquerading as the UFESM.
 
This is to inform the general public that the only duly constituted ESM body with the acronym UFESM is the one functioning at JM for the last 100 days under the Chairmanship of Lt Col Inderjit Singh, the doyen of OROP.
 
The meeting as described was a collection of individuals with little or no lien towards the issues facing the ESM or a following in number of members barring a handful. Also case had been made out so as to legitimise their being by bringing in Anna Hazare, who it seems from their self confessed mail, has parted company with them. They have also tried to create an atmosphere of officer bashing by a section of disgruntled JCO & OR who seem to be trying to avenge their in service grudges through this forum. Overall a sad commentary whose specific instigator is one Col Dinesh Nain, an erstwhile coordinator of the Anna Hazare Movement. Measures are being undertaken by UFESM, technically and legally to cull this crowd.
 
Col Anil Kaul, VrC
Media Advisor UFESM
 
 
 

JANTAR MANTAR TODAY 22 SEP MORNING AT 1200 CROWD EXCEEDED 700.. Part 1 pics courtesy mrs DEEPA NEBB
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Monday, September 21, 2015

OROP: Stop Misleading the People and Come out with the Arithmetic

SOURCE :http://blogs.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/In-search-of-propriety/orop-stop-misleading-the-people-and-come-out-with-the-arithmetic/





               





                                SARKARI   POLICY  IN  MOD

                          EVERY ONE FROM MY CLAN 

                                     IS

                      "CHIEF OF STAFF"
                                     IN

            MINISTRY OF DEFENCE "


                                                                  AND

                     U GUYS FROM AFS
                                     
Josh Blue Comedy's photo.

                   DON'T  U KNOW FOR 
 
                             "OROP" 

 TILL DATE WE  HAVE NO ARITHMETIC




           OROP: Stop Misleading the People 

                                  and

            Come out with the Arithmetic

                                    By

                  Brig  V Mahalingam (retd)







September 21, 2015, 




The article ‘It’s time to analyze OROP with our head, not our heart’ reveals the myopic view of some, born out of ignorance and lack of understanding which needs to be corrected lest the country falls prey to such distortions. 
In some cases such views are motivated and prompted.

The “public good will” which the author says the defence services enjoy loses all its import when a soldier is made to struggle to feed his family and finds no way to educate his children with his meagre pension. Under such circumstances, all talk of a soldier’s sacrifice in the line of duty, discipline etc. gives the impression of a mocking glee after being exploited, particularly so when he has been rendered voiceless. 

Do we realise that the retirement benefits which a soldier receives at the time of retirement is spent in the education of his young school going children and in marrying them off besides augmenting the short fall in his monthly budget?
 Are we aware that retiring 20 years later with the benefits of at least two subsequent Pay Commissions and increases due to increments, promotions and dearness relief added, the retirement benefits and pensions of a civilian is much higher than a soldier?

 Can we not see the disparity? 

Do we as a society realise that while a soldier is in service, his family suffers due to his absence and the constant anxiety of risks to his life and limbs while after his retirement it is the state of penury that plagues them.


OROP

Post retirement, are we as a country expecting the soldiers to go begging with their family behind them after having risked their lives guarding the borders in inhospitable terrain and weather conditions staying away from their near and dear ones?
 Is good living and the privilege of educating their children with aspirations for their future only the preserve of those who can manage their career and lives with income from both legal and other sources? 
Are soldiers not entitled to live with dignity and pride of a retired warrior? Or should they perish as defeats in the streets of this great country?
The author seems to be complaining that “people who wanted to do an objective analysis had to scurry and hide in a corner?”  
If indeed some people have sprinted away, taken cover and gone mute it is nothing but their feeling of guilt and an attempt to hide facts from the people of this country.
 When the author says that the “government estimated a liability of around Rs 12,000 crores per year to just implement this one recommendation”, is he not telling a lie? 
What is he attempting to convey when he says “per year”? 
Is he not trying to misrepresent facts? 
Is that not aimed at misleading the people? 


Is the author aware that the soldiers were 
cheated in broad daylight in 1973 by 
reducing the officers’ pension from 70 % of 
last pay drawn to 50 % and that of the 
soldiers from 70 to 37 % with a promise of 
OROP yet to be delivered?


Does anyone know the financial implications of OROP as per the government’s calculations? 
Till date the government has not spoken a word about it. Why are we writing about an issue without even knowing the facts?
 Before penning that article, I wish the author had done some homework to understand the ‘arithmetic’ of this scheme which this good governance government has been working out for the past one year! 

Is it not sheer intellectual dishonesty to write something without knowing the facts thereby spreading falsehood?



orop1

The military veterans want the “arithmetic” of this scheme as worked out by the government which seems to be scaring them to be put out in the public domain. This will enable the people of the country to see the actual financial liability and the scheming ways of those who are attempting to block this benefit to the Veterans. Let me assure one and all, if indeed this scheme is going to cost “tens of thousands of crores” as being falsely propagated, many of the Veterans would stick their neck out to moderate the demand. If the government fails to place facts in the open, it would be for no other reason than to cheat the Veterans.
The author’s statement “should we still say give them whatever they want because they guard our borders (by the way the “Border Security Force or BSF does not get OROP?)”, is yet another propaganda tool of the government to confuse the issue. 
The military is not demanding OROP because they are guarding the borders. It is to compensate the soldiering community for their early retirement. The loss to overall life time income of an officer due to early retirement is to the tune of rupees one crore and that of the other ranks is about rupees 80 lakhs. This is not including the increased retirement benefits, the perks and facilities which one enjoys by serving up to 60 years of age. 
The central armed police force personnel do not retire at the young age of 35 / 40 or their officers at the age of 54 as in the case of defence services officers. 
The question is why should a soldier earn less than his civilian counterpart? Are they doing an inferior job? Or are they the second class citizens of this country?
The author’s statement “in a country of limited 
resources like India, an expense as big as 
OROP must be examined carefully and kept 
in limits” is a very welcome assertion.

 Did anyone question the impact of tax exemptions to the tune of Rs 62398.6 crores to the corporates, a figure 8% higher than the previous financial year 2013 – 2014, an ever-increasing loss in perpetuity year after year? 
What about the non-performing assets in the public sector banks which stood at Rs 2, 27,264 crores at the end of 2014 of which Rs 34,620 crores have been written off this financial year (FY)? 
Aren’t the balance amounts going to be written off in due course of time without even debating it publically, unlike the OROP? 
What about the agricultural loan waiver of Rs 60,000 crores which went up to Rs 71680 crores during the FY 2007–08? 
Many complain even today that the small farmers and the poor did not get the relief. What about the Rs 2.79 lakh crores written off during the same FY, the tax and duty dues to the government? 
The combined loss to BSNL and MTNL during the FY 2014–15 is to the tune of Rs 53.52 billion rupees. Were these losses to the tax payer “examined carefully” and were they not “big” enough?

orop2

The author states “we pay defence pensions of around Rs 60,000 crores per year. OROP will add another Rs 12,000 crores to it annually”. This is unsubstantiated data and is sheer falsehood, probably created to scare the common man. The defence ministry’s pension bill for the FY 2015–16 incidentally as per official documents is Rs 54,500 crores. Of these it is learnt that approximately Rs 22500 crores is spent on the pension of civil pensioners of the ministry. The author may like to check on his facts.
                              HARAM  KA  KAMAI
While implementing the 6th Central Pay Commission’s (CPC) recommendations, the government granted Non Functional Financial Upgradation (NFFU) to all officers of the Organised Group A Services (58 Services) under a logic “most of the services still have a great degree of stagnation at Senior Administrative Grade (SAG) and Higher Administrative Grade (HAG) levels”.
 The NFFU is the financial upgradation to an officer of the service irrespective of the place or his appointment as and when an officer of his batch is posted to an appointment tenable by SAG or HAG grade of pay. By this process, every officer of these services will reach the apex scales during their service which will automatically entail them to receive OROP. Compare this to the stagnation in promotion in the defence services. It is only 0.8 % army officers who reach the level of major generals, equivalent of Joint Secretaries after 28 years of service while 100 % officers of these services reach that rank in 19 years of their service. Pray tell me where exactly is the stagnation? Why this twist in logic?

Where did the logic of “country of limited resources” and “an expense as big as OROP must be examined carefully and kept in limits” vanish when the Indian bureaucracy indulged in serving their own self surreptitiously? Are we aware of the way the bureaucracy has managed treatment for themselves abroad? If not read Treatment abroad: Government to reimburse the total cost incurred by bureaucrats. The story of how the bureaucrats had granted for themselves two additional increments beyond those sanctioned by the Union cabinet is available at Primus Inter Predators? Do these advantages to the bureaucracy not have financial implications? Why are we as a nation blind to these transgressions and chose to question only OROP which is the legitimate demand of the military veterans?
Let us now think about these issues “with our head”? Why not have the same retirement ages for the civil services too like the defence services, the officers retiring at the age of 54 and the others after 15 to 25 years of service depending on their rank? Let us have the same proportion of vacancies in various ranks and similar promotion system to avoid disparity.  We will be thus providing the unemployed youth of this country increased job opportunities and will enable greater turnover of personnel in government services. In such a scenario, there will be no case for OROP to anyone.
Questions like “to pay the veterans more or to pay new hires in the army more” posed at the end of the article only confirms a soldier’s suspicion that he has been used and is now being considered expended material to be allowed to perish without incurring any further expenditure. Such ungrateful thought besides rubbishing a soldier’s sacrifices in his younger days has very serious repercussions on the morale, the risk taking spirit and the sacrificing attitude of the serving soldiers. Don’t forget when a serving soldier sees a veteran being treated the way he has been, he knows his future.
When a government breaches its part of the unwritten obligation to a soldier to take care of him and his family in his sunset years, can the soldier remain unaffected? Will he falter in his commitment to kill and get killed if need be to protect the integrity, dignity, honor, values and objectives of the nation on behalf of the people?